Luigi's Pizzeria
(0.48mi)Italian, Pizza
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
1372 NY-25A,
Setauket- East Setauket,
NY
(631) 751-3400
Mario's
(0.74mi)Italian
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
Old School House Square, 212 Main St,
Setauket- East Setauket,
NY
(631) 751-8840
Stone Soupe
(2.58mi)Deli, Italian
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
232 N Belle Mead Rd,
Setauket- East Setauket,
NY
(631) 675-1930
The Pie
(2.06mi)Italian, Pizza
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
216 Main St,
Port Jefferson,
NY
(631) 331-4646
Joey Z's Restaurant
(2.08mi)Breakfast & Brunch, Italian, Mediterranean
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
217 Main St,
Port Jefferson,
NY
(631) 476-7510
Setauket Pastaria
(2.47mi)Italian, Pizza
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
4082 Nesconset Hwy,
Setauket- East Setauket,
NY
(631) 476-8600
Old Town Pizza
(3.88mi)Italian, Pizza
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
691 Old Town Rd,
Port Jefferson Station,
NY
(631) 473-3712
Amici Restaurant
(4.04mi)Italian, Pizza
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
304 NY-25A,
Mt Sinai,
NY
(631) 473-2400
O Sole Mio
(4.17mi)Italian, Pizza
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
2194 Nesconset Hwy A,
Stony Brook,
NY
(631) 751-1600
Cafe Spiga
(4.47mi)Italian, Pizza
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
176 N Country Rd,
Mt Sinai,
NY
(631) 331-5554
Savino's Hideaway
(4.81mi)Italian, Pizza
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
258 N Country Rd,
Mt Sinai,
NY
(631) 928-6510
La Grova Ristorante
(4.96mi)Italian, Pizza
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
2799 Middle Country Rd,
Lake Grove,
NY
(631) 981-4940
Michael Anthony's Pizzeria & Restaurant
(5.04mi)Gluten-Free, Italian, Pizza
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
2425 Middle Country Rd,
Centereach,
NY
(631) 285-7722
Spuntino St James
(5.16mi)Italian, Pizza
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
420 N Country Rd,
St James,
NY
(631) 686-6700
Villa Grazia
(5.18mi)Italian, Pizza
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
1665 Middle Country Rd,
Centereach,
NY
(631) 732-3372
Villa Sorrento
(5.33mi)Diners, Italian
✓ Takeout
823 Middle Country Rd,
St James,
NY
(631) 265-9865
Rocco's Amici Express Pizzeria
(5.40mi)Italian, Pizza
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
1028 NY-25A,
Mt Sinai,
NY
(631) 928-0100